Advertise on fullfatrr.com »

Home > Off Topic - Other Cars > Another review on electric cars - This time it's JLR!
Post Reply  Down to end
Page 1 of 4 1234>
Print this entire topic · 
aja500



Member Since: 15 Oct 2017
Location: South East
Posts: 815

United Kingdom 2019 Range Rover Autobiography 5.0 SC V8 Aruba
Another review on electric cars - This time it's JLR!

I just thought I'd share this article; this one was written in The Times Newspaper (so nothing to do with the Daily Mail).

It's a "must read" as far as I'm concerned, especially if you're considering an electric FFRR any time soon, or maybe even not so soon!

It's written by Giles Coren. For those who don't know, he's the restaurant critic who does the great hotels of the world TV programme with top female Chef, Monica Galetti and he's also the brother of Victoria Coren Mitchell, David Mitchell's wife,

This is his own first-hand experience of ownership and while amusing, unfortunately, it doesn't sound good.

Giles Coren - Why I’ve pulled the plug on my electric car

As I watch my family strike out on foot across the fields into driving rain and gathering darkness, my wife holding each child’s hand, our new year plans in ruins, while I do what I can to make our dead car safe before abandoning it a mile short of home, full of luggage on a country lane, it occurs to me not for the first time that if we are going to save the planet we will have to find another way. Because electric cars are not the answer.

Yes, it’s the Jaguar again. My doomed bloody £65,000 iPace that has done nothing but fail at everything it was supposed to do for more than two years now, completely dead this time, its lifeless corpse blocking the single-track road.
I can’t even roll it to a safer spot because it can’t be put in neutral. For when an electric car dies, it dies hard. And then lies there as big and grey and not-going-anywhere as the poacher-slain bull elephant I once saw rotting by a roadside in northern Kenya. Just a bit less smelly.

Not that this is unusual. Since I bought my eco dream car in late 2020, in a deluded Thunbergian frenzy, it has spent more time off the road than on it, beached at the dealership for months at a time on account of innumerable electrical calamities, while I galumph around in the big diesel “courtesy cars” they send me under the terms of the warranty.
But this time I don’t want one. And I don’t want my own car back either. I have asked the guys who sold it to me to sell it again, as soon as it is fixed, to the first mug who walks into the shop. Because I am going back to petrol while there is still time.

And if the government really does ban new wet fuel cars after 2030, then we will eventually have to go back to horses. Because the electric vehicle industry is no readier to get a family home from Cornwall at Christmas time (as I was trying to do) than it is to fly us all to Jupiter. The cars are useless, the infrastructure is not there and you’re honestly better off walking. Even on the really long journeys. In fact, especially on the long journeys. The short ones they can just about manage. It’s no wonder Tesla shares are down 71 per cent. It’s all a huge fraud. And, for me, it’s over.

Yet the new owner of my “preloved” premium electric vehicle, fired with a messianic desire to make a better world for his children, will not know this. He will be delighted with his purchase and overjoyed to find there are still six months of warranty left, little suspecting that once that has expired — and with it the free repairs and replacement cars for those long spells off road — he will be functionally carless.

He will be over the moon to learn that it has “a range of up to 292 miles”. No need to tell him what that really means is “220 miles”. Why electric carmakers are allowed to tell these lies is a mystery to me. As it soon will be to him.

Although for the first few days he won’t worry especially. He’ll think he can just nip into a fuel station and charge it up again. Ho ho ho. No need to tell him that two out of three roadside chargers in this country are broken or busy at any one time. Or that the built-in “find my nearest charge point” function doesn’t work, has never worked, and isn’t meant to work.
Or that apps like Zap-Map don’t work either because the chargers they send you to are always either busy or broken or require a membership card you don’t have or an app you can’t download because there’s no 5G here, in the middle of nowhere, where you will now probably die.
Or that the Society of Motor Manufacturers said this week that only 23 new chargers are being installed nationwide each day, of the 100 per day that were promised (as a proud early adopter, I told myself that charging would become easier as the network grew, but it hasn’t grown, while the number of e-drivers has tripled, so it’s actually harder now than it was two years ago).

There are, of course, plus sides to electric ownership. Such as the camaraderie when we encounter each other, tired and weeping at yet another service station with only two chargers, one of which still has the “this fault has been reported” sign on it from when you were here last August, and the other is of the measly 3kWh variety, which means you will have to spend the night in a Travelodge while your stupid drum lazily inhales enough juice to get home.

Together, in the benighted charging zone, we leccy drivers laugh about what fools we are and drool over the diesel hatchbacks nonchalantly filling up across the way (“imagine getting to a fuel station and knowing for sure you will be able to refuel!”) and talk in the hour-long queue at Exeter services about the petrol car we will buy as soon as we get home.

We filled up there last week on the way back from Cornwall, adding two hours to our four-hour journey, by which time Esther wasn’t speaking to me. She’s been telling me to get rid of the iPace since it ruined last summer’s holidays in both Wales and Devon (“If you won’t let us fly any more, at least buy a car that can get us to the places we’re still allowed to go!”).

But I kept begging her to give me one last chance, as if I’d refused to give up a mistress, rather than a dull family car. Until this time, a couple of miles from home, when a message flashed up on the dash: “Assisted braking not available — proceed with caution.” Then: “Steering control unavailable.”
And then, as I inched off the dual carriageway at our turnoff, begging it to make the last mile, children weeping at the scary noises coming from both car and father: “Gearbox fault detected.” CLUNK. WHIRRR. CRACK.
And dead. Nothing. Poached elephant.

I called Jaguar Assist (there is a button in the roof that does it directly — most useful feature on the car) who told me they could have a mechanic there in four hours (who would laugh and say, “Can’t help you, pal. You’ve got a software issue there. I’m just a car mechanic. And this isn’t a car, it’s a laptop on wheels.”)

So Esther and the kids headed for home across the sleety wastes, a vision of post-apocalyptic misery like something out of Cormac McCarthy, while I saw out 2022 waiting for a tow-truck. Again.
But don’t let that put you off. I see in the paper that electric car sales are at record levels and production is struggling to keep up with demand. So why not buy mine? It’s clean as a whistle and boasts super-low mileage. After all, it’s hardly been driven . . .

Post #652967 8th Jan 2023 12:46pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
Tinman



Member Since: 22 Mar 2017
Location: kent
Posts: 1120

United Kingdom 2017 Range Rover Autobiography SDV8 Silicon Silver

Put you in mind when the Government told us it was a good idea to buy diesel cars and we know how that went Big Cry Time will tell, it a great idea but not well thought out.If electric cars were so good why did they stop making them?

1920 – 1935
Improved road infrastructure and cheap, widely available gasoline contributed to a decline in electric vehicles. Electric cars were limited to use in cities due to their slow speed and low range, and by 1935 they had all but disappeared.

We no longer have improved roads pot holes every where and not so cheap fuel here unlike other parts of the world. Whistle 2017 SDV8 4.4 silicon silver AB
2012 TDV8 4.4 Stornaway Grey AB
2011 TDV8 4.4 Buckingham Blue
2012 VW V6 3.0 Tougreg

Post #652991 8th Jan 2023 2:50pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
AJGalaxy2012



Member Since: 11 Jun 2018
Location: Gainsborough
Posts: 1446

United Kingdom 2012 Range Rover Vogue SE 4.4 V8 Bonatti Grey

Much of that is about the choice of vehicle rather than the category of vehicle. JLR are not good in the reliability stakes and definitely abysmal in customer care.
He mentions the range not being achievable, is that any different to an ICE vehicle, have you managed to achieve the figures published?
I do agree about the charging points, I have found many of them to be faulty, none of them work in the same way, when they do work it's great. BMW i3 Electric Car
2012 Full Fat RR 4.4 TDV8 (now gone)
2006 VW Touareg 3.0 TDi V6

Post #652996 8th Jan 2023 3:05pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
Kot



Member Since: 10 Mar 2021
Location: broadland
Posts: 1069

United Kingdom 

AJA500 thanks for that, a very amusing read, I can imagine the country lane and the darkness but most of all the quietness Laughing 2018 SE SDV8 4.4 Byron Blue

Post #653004 8th Jan 2023 4:03pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
dhallworth



Member Since: 10 Oct 2011
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 2950

United Kingdom 2012 Range Rover Autobiography TDV8 Baltic Blue

My folks have got a 22MY I-Pace HSE that they bought new and have had for a little over a year and 8500 miles now.

They’ve not had a single issue with theirs and it’s been great.

If I didn’t need the 3600kg towing limit I’d have one in a heartbeat.

David. 2002 4.6 Vogue SE - Alveston Red with Lightstone Leather
2007 Range Rover Supercharged in Java Black with Ivory Leather
2012 Range Rover 5.0 SC Autobiography in Indus Silver with Jet/Ivory Interior
2012 Range Rover 4.4 TDV8 Autobiography in Baltic Blue with Sand Interior

Post #653007 8th Jan 2023 4:24pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
Paul J.



Member Since: 13 Jan 2009
Location: Leafy Cheshire
Posts: 277

England 

Ironically, the main issue that I-Paces have had is with their 12v lead acid batteries - the symptoms reported by Mr Coren suggest a fubarred auxiliary battery.

I’ve had mine for 4 years and bought it outright at the end of the finance period, because it is the best car I’ve owned. Gone D3
Gone FFRR L322
Gone FFRR L405
Now on the JLR electric highway ....

Post #653039 8th Jan 2023 10:29pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
AJGalaxy2012



Member Since: 11 Jun 2018
Location: Gainsborough
Posts: 1446

United Kingdom 2012 Range Rover Vogue SE 4.4 V8 Bonatti Grey

The 12v battery seems to cause issues on most makes of EV. Hyundai, Kia, VW and BMW for sure. BMW i3 Electric Car
2012 Full Fat RR 4.4 TDV8 (now gone)
2006 VW Touareg 3.0 TDi V6

Post #653047 9th Jan 2023 2:04am
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
TJH1985



Member Since: 11 Feb 2015
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 663

United Kingdom 2007 Range Rover Vogue SE TDV8 Java Black

I had a 300mile round trip in a friends Tesla last week and although the cars not for me (allot of cash for not a great build imo) the tech was superb!

He had enough range to get home, but wanted to top up so he had juice to head out again straight after, the car showed him all the charging points and even how many were in use etc, so he choose a services where the majority were not in use, plugged it in while we nipped to the loo and in that short period it added 55miles of range which I thought was impressive.

The Tesla charger recognised the car, so no need to do anything other than plug in.

I quite enjoyed the whole experience to be honest. Sold - Bell a 2015 MY16 Loire Blue Autobiography 4.4 SDV8
Previously George a 2007 MY07 Java Black VSE 3.6 TDV8
Previously a 04 MY04 Defender 90 Sad

Post #653048 9th Jan 2023 7:32am
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
SamThomas



Member Since: 12 Nov 2021
Location: South East
Posts: 293

United Kingdom 2003 Range Rover Vogue Td6 Baltic Blue

I read the article word for word & all the replies & have come to the following conclusions.

EV.s are not for everyone. (For those where it works for them good luck).

We as consumers must still have a choice.

It does point out a serious flaw in EV design though & that's the inability to move a completely dead EV to a save place or even to move it out of the way of other vehicles. Just suppose in the case quoted the dead EV blocked access to an emergency vehicle ?

Post #653062 9th Jan 2023 11:29am
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
JayGee



Member Since: 27 Jul 2021
Location: London
Posts: 2567

United Kingdom 2012 Range Rover Vogue 4.4 V8 Orkney Grey

EV's are in their infancy and what problems exist now can't be predicted to exist in future models or as a reason to stick with ICE's for ever. As consumers we won't have absolute freedom of choice now as we can't buy new diesel engine cars that don't have DPF's or petrol cars without CAT's. 2012 TDV8 Vogue (L322)

Post #653066 9th Jan 2023 11:58am
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
cass



Member Since: 12 Oct 2011
Location: northumberland
Posts: 691

United Kingdom 2014 Range Rover Autobiography SDV8 Causeway Grey

SamThomas wrote:

It does point out a serious flaw in EV design though & that's the inability to move a completely dead EV to a save place or even to move it out of the way of other vehicles. Just suppose in the case quoted the dead EV blocked access to an emergency vehicle ?


I never pictured myself defending EV's but this issue is just the same with almost any modern car with an auto gearbox or electric handbrake.
Most owners wouldn't have a clue about the emergency release system.

Post #653082 9th Jan 2023 4:47pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
aja500



Member Since: 15 Oct 2017
Location: South East
Posts: 815

United Kingdom 2019 Range Rover Autobiography 5.0 SC V8 Aruba

It's good to read all your comments - I just thought it was an amusing article and of course a bit of an eyeopener from someone who has experienced two years of JLR full electric ownership.

Of course real world range is almost always different to manufacturer's quoted figures, often these claims are unachievable and based on what was realised in perfect / unrealistic conditions, but that bothers me much less when I'm not planning journeys based on it and when I know I'm never very far from a petrol station, where I can quickly and easily refuel.

At the end of the day, "you pay your money, you take your choice" - each to their own.

I'm not completely against battery cars, I currently have an L460 PHEV on order and I'm looking forward to some journeys being silent and free of engine noise, but would I dare to commit to "a car for all journeys" without the back up of a petrol engine anytime soon, or in 2024 when JLR are aiming to release their fully electric L460, personally, no I wouldn't and this article gives plenty of support to my concerns.

Post #653089 9th Jan 2023 5:55pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
RRV8SC



Member Since: 02 Oct 2021
Location: SW London
Posts: 142

United Kingdom 2015 Range Rover Autobiography 5.0 SC V8 Santorini Black

JayGee wrote:
EV's are in their infancy and what problems exist now can't be predicted to exist in future models or as a reason to stick with ICE's for ever. As consumers we won't have absolute freedom of choice now as we can't buy new diesel engine cars that don't have DPF's or petrol cars without CAT's.


The Nissan Leaf was launched in 2010. I'm became interested in 2013 when the BMW i3 was launched.

I currently have a 2019 VW e-Golf for local trips and occasional longer round trips of up to 120 miles.

I bought the Golf on PCP with a GFV simply because I was worried that 3 years later I would have an old fashioned out of date dud, superseded by 3 years of technical advancement. Yes, I wanted that GFV.

Well, I had no need to worry as nothing much has changed. There are EV with longer ranges but only because they have managed to cram in more batteries, no real technical advancement.

And as regard to the public charging network, I always look at every journey longer than 120 mile journey to see how well that might go. It never does with a combination of rapid chargers few and far between, out of service or with some prices so high that my V8 5.0 isn't significantly more expensive. And the worry is that if I took the chance, the charger may be blocked by someone else charging.

My last longer distance journey was Christmas Eve from my house to Witney, a journey of 73 miles, so I could get there but at some point would have to charge to get back. I identified 2 possibilities. One at a MSA and another 5 miles from Witney. The MSA was chocker, no chance and the 5 miles from Witney was out of service. Good job I took my RR then. Anecdotal but repeated so many times one way or another over the last 3 years.

So as much as I enjoy my e-Golf, I'm not sure that it's in in infancy, more like it's early teens and all the issues that go with that.

Post #653095 9th Jan 2023 6:23pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
aja500



Member Since: 15 Oct 2017
Location: South East
Posts: 815

United Kingdom 2019 Range Rover Autobiography 5.0 SC V8 Aruba

Thanks for sharing your experience RRV8SC.

I get the feeling that electric cars are great for local runs, but it seems a certain amount of planning is usually required for longer journeys, which I'm not sure would work for me.

Post #653109 9th Jan 2023 7:48pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
dhallworth



Member Since: 10 Oct 2011
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 2950

United Kingdom 2012 Range Rover Autobiography TDV8 Baltic Blue

I took my folks I-Pace from 17 miles West of Glasgow to North Wales and back in 24hrs in July last year to collect a pair of cylinder heads for my L322.

We left home with it 100% charged. A quick 25 minute stop at Gretna Services for a cup of coffee and a top up charge (£15.92 rapid charge) saw us arriving at the hotel at Chester Services with 66 miles range left.

We left the hotel with 100% charged the next morning (£5.22 overnight charge), collected the cylinder heads and then headed back for home. Another 25 minute top up charge whilst grabbing a cup of coffee at Gretna (£14.20) gave us enough range to get home with 36 miles of range left.

In total it was 516 miles covered for a total cost of £35.34. It’s the first time I’d covered any distance in the IPace and must admit, I was really impressed. There have been times where they’ve had to wait a while for a charger and times they’ve found chargers that don’t work but it’s not been a big issue for them.

The I-Pace for them isn’t their only car, they’ve got 4 other cars that they use alongside the I-Pace, although, the only car they’ve done long distance in over the last 14 months has been the I-Pace. Their I-Pace replaced a 3.2 Freelander 2, initially I wasn’t convinced as I was trying to push them towards an F-Pace SVR. They chose the I-Pace though and I’m really taken by it.

David. 2002 4.6 Vogue SE - Alveston Red with Lightstone Leather
2007 Range Rover Supercharged in Java Black with Ivory Leather
2012 Range Rover 5.0 SC Autobiography in Indus Silver with Jet/Ivory Interior
2012 Range Rover 4.4 TDV8 Autobiography in Baltic Blue with Sand Interior

Post #653113 9th Jan 2023 8:26pm
View user's profile Send private message View poster's gallery Reply with quote
Post Reply  Back to top
Page 1 of 4 1234>
All times are GMT

Jump to  
Previous Topic | Next Topic >
Posting Rules
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



Site Copyright © 2006-2024 Futuranet Ltd & Martin Lewis
fullfatrr.com RSS Feed - All Forums


Switch to Mobile site